Cleveland Police and Crime Commissioner Matt Storey has renewed his opposition to police force mergers, joining 30 other signatories in a letter warning of “substantial consequences” for communities, victims and witnesses.
The joint letter, signed by police and crime commissioners (PCCs) and mayoral representatives, comes as a government-commissioned review considers replacing the current 43 police forces in England and Wales with eight to ten larger regional forces.
A separate proposal could also see the creation of a new national police service, bringing together responsibilities currently held by the National Crime Agency, the College of Policing and other functions, including police air support.
The letter warns that merging forces could disrupt ongoing criminal investigations and weaken local accountability and democracy.

However, senior police figures have argued that reform could help overstretched forces tackle increasingly complex crime.
Metropolitan Police chief Sir Mark Rowley recently said forces were trying to do too much with too little, suggesting mergers could reduce duplication and free up thousands of roles for frontline policing.
He argued that organised crime groups, fraud networks, cyber-criminals and those involved in online child abuse increasingly operate across regional and international borders, while police forces remain organised around local areas.
Cleveland police leaders divided over mergers

Cleveland Chief Constable Victoria Fuller has suggested that a single North East-wide police force could make sense, potentially providing greater resources and specialist capabilities.
Her position contrasts with that of Mr Storey, who warned in September that a merger could simply create a larger, equally cash-strapped force without additional investment.
Greater Manchester Police Chief Constable Sir Stephen Watson has also supported reform, describing the current policing system as “sub-optimal” and warning that without changes it would continue to go backwards.
Mr Storey said: “The people of Cleveland deserve a police service that understands the distinct challenges and opportunities across Hartlepool, Middlesbrough, Redcar and Cleveland, and Stockton-on-Tees.
“Local policing works best when local priorities are shaped by local people and when communities can clearly see who is accountable for the service they receive.
“Any proposal of this scale must be backed by clear evidence that it will improve public safety, strengthen accountability and deliver better value for taxpayers.
“Given the challenges facing policing, the Government must also demonstrate why force mergers would deliver greater benefits than investing in frontline policing and fairer funding.
“At present, that case has not been made.”
MP warns of years of upheaval
Stockton West MP Matt Vickers, who holds the Conservatives’ shadow crime and policing brief, also criticised the proposals, warning that mergers could lead to “years of upheaval and enormous cost”.
He said: “When even Labour’s own police and crime commissioner is telling Andy Burnham to think again, the Prime Minister should listen.
“I’m all for forces working together where it makes sense locally.
“But replacing more than 40 forces with eight or ten regional giants is a different thing entirely.”
The proposals remain under consideration, with supporters arguing that larger forces could improve efficiency and specialist policing, while opponents fear a loss of local accountability and disruption to services.


